Life is full of surprises, and for David Tolley, one unexpected moment changed the course of his life. On December 19, 1985, he was a member of the studio audience for The Tonight Show, hosted by Johnny Carson, when the unexpected happened. Carson announced that the scheduled guest, a classical pianist named Horatio Gutierrez, had injured his hand and wouldn’t be able to perform. Without missing a beat, Carson asked if anyone in the audience could play the piano.

Tolley, who had been playing piano since childhood, immediately volunteered. He took to the stage and performed “Memory” from the popular musical Cats. The impromptu performance earned him a standing ovation from the audience and a new level of recognition.

The day after the show, Tolley’s phone started ringing off the hook. He received calls from people offering him gigs on cruise ships, acting roles in movies, and more. His life had been forever changed by a chance encounter on a late-night talk show. The story of Tolley’s unexpected success serves as a reminder that we never know what opportunities or challenges might come our way in life, and that it’s important to be prepared to take advantage of them when they do.